A look at recent automotive news will show you that EV manufacturers are slashing charging times in an effort to compete with the amount of time you would spend at a gas station. Andrew Cornelia, the CEO of Mercedes-Benz High-Power Charging, called this into question on a recent episode of Inside EV’s Plugged-In podcast, claiming that many automakers could be overreaching.

And he may have a point.

We recently reported that BYD, a Chinese automaker, had laid out plans for a 1,000 kW charging solution that would effectively quadruple the amount of electricity that any Tesla model can currently accept. In theory, it sounds great. We always welcome new technology, and so does Cornelia, but he has some very interesting insight about how we should approach juicing up EVs.

Charging Times Now
Tesla’s 3rd-generation Superchargers can supply up to 250 kW of power, able to add approximately 175-200 miles of range in 15 minutes. With Tesla and many other automakers continuing to steadily slash charging times, Cornelia says we could be closer to the Goldilocks zone than we think. He says that charge times of 10, even 12 minutes, would be perfectly acceptable given the time that motorists tend to “dwell” at the gas station.

We car enthusiasts like to think we’re pretty economical with our time at the gas station, but let’s face it, we’re actually not. While it may only take four minutes to fill up with fuel, that’s only the amuse bouche of gas station amenities. Most of us might need to go inside and use the facilities, and maybe even snag a beverage and a snack if we’re on an extended road trip. Some gas stations will even have more substantial food options like sandwiches or even fast food chains if you’re especially lucky.

After all is said and done, it’s pretty easy to find yourself at the gas station for longer than 10 minutes. Just whatever you do, don’t park at the pump if you have to venture inside for any accoutrement. Nobody wants to wait for you to complete your weekly grocery shop when they’re just looking to top up with fuel.

Keeping Busy at Charging Stations
Cornelia noted that rather than going for outright speed, the charging experience should match the dwell time—adding that there are rarely scenarios where uber-fast charging makes sense. For this exact reason, Mercedes is laying plans to build its upcoming charging stations at points of interest like Starbucks and even Buc-ee’s, a Southern chain of mega gas stations.

All this talk against ultra-fast charging doesn’t mean that Mercedes-Benz isn’t committed to optimizing fast charging for those who need it. Far from it. Many of us don’t have access to a garage that would allow us to slowly add range overnight. Mercedes-Benz High-Power Charging still plans to offer 400 kW charging stations, with more than enough muscle to juice up almost any EV in mere moments. For context, Tesla’s 4th-generation Superchargers won’t be much better, quoting a 500 kW output.